白春礼：以重大成果产出为导向改革科技评价.pdf

&' ! " ! " $ % % & ' ( ) * & %+ " + " !"#$%&'()* +,-./0 !" #$%& '()*+ ,- .//012 !! "" !# "$%&'()*+,-./01%23456789':;<=>? @()ABCDEFG'H*+AIJKLMNOPQ&RST%UVW()AB CDLXYEZ[\]:%^_Q1`Z,abcQdeL()fgh[i8(; jkl*+ #$# $mLnoXY\]:%_QCD()fg%JpZ,abcQdeL fgAIiqrstWuZ,abcQvdeCD()fgLZwMxEZ,a bcQL(yz{%|}W8(;Z,abcQdeL~!"fgAIi#$8 (;%v()'H&% .()ABCD8'()*+,%-i !#$%" 8'(y;%Z,abcQ%()fg %&' .($) *+ "+, ) . / / 0) ($$ $1 * $23) #$( #) $2 ) $$ ( !# "$% &'()*+,-./01% 23456789':!;<=>?()@ ABCD EF'G*+@HIJKLMN OP QRS;LMN TUV&WXY% Z[\]' 8*+7+,-d (()*+,-./0123456 789:;<-"=> ()@ABCK^_D `abc:d.() uZ,abcQvdeCD()fg% efBCgW% hi1j`,klmVno /*+01'`L23w4d8w%]'9 pK()efqadrn()'Gs% 8( :.;<=>zjg?D EFIJ*+6' !tuv.&'()@ABCKwx% `y GD @A(BzjK 7 / ?@) 7 > ) > 0 ()*+,-./# $( #0 !1 !- O+K()ef% Tob|}f*+g@h i,()jk% `alFmA)nCoD p !" ! " # !" ! " ! " ! " " # $ % & ' # "( ) ( ) !"#$%&'()*+,-"#./0123 z]^= z}R,m(3RB|{3|Yw%}= 456(789:;<= >?@ABCDEFGH ~P{!},H "#($0+zQR= &!UVQ IJKLCMNOMP(QRISTUVWX+ Z"kq 3;56= >?YZ[\]^_H `S[a(Wb cd0)*A;<56= efghijk[789 :;?@ A0BC= DnZ&EFGHIJKLMNO(% _= PQ3RB|SVFTUVnWX^YH Z[ \]= Vn5^_`ab= Vncdveq3RB V},NOqUVQZ"k-.DAH/HA/ 0E = `/123 QGUV3456= b4,1~= >?789:;<= @578QG1F= QZj6j z"MUV7@()8X= @k9UV:;0<= 2A= NO=z!(h>?9[\[@U/:;0 'AB[1pYB0UVQ8= =&!3CD,T smEm1p9UV},q |fNghi_ej3;},= kBlmnoH : EF"#-GHIq`/2GQG.g'F PpqHUFrMTBC=stkB3Ruvn WG0UV3456= H()7@./H [acd oq3Rwx0nyz4{|.vw}~0! h0783456qIJ= K>.BhLM0=d "q#$Kt3;vwH &'w%}~= &'EF NOPQR= Sb.Tb DUVMWXYZE 0V vw(()0*+}~= >kR,MF(L\N [= z\[\3;]0^_7`(Aavw= Hb O= !I-.WX/0H Z[wxH BjwxT1p Pk[=cMVxR,0d12YB.e]'f 0Kt= 234,3;},560},MP78= 0UVQZg h*Aij}0T7kU/>?= B 2613;smKt0*9:;q 8[\yn^_Gy= l! " # $ % " $ mbvo De]n !"#$%&'()*+,-./012<= # "r= [;<= # " )> >?@ ! " !" A7BC8Dq!" ?;@ABACD.h3< D}, ! " ! " E 1F= G HIJKLLMN!},xO= P_QG77[a d o ( R S . / 0 U V 3 ; 5 6 q L MD } , ! " ! " E Nu= h3?(Ughi1~qoL B D}, ! " ! " E 0)*[H(:;= ! " # !rj= h3 V34!/E q JK@L*q`/2@k,0x*`oHG Npq= .B,BCHU/VMs7r@k,0x *Qs= ./TN,1t^x*uvB8_a= H .V,0wxeIb4,0R,'FqIJ= yE fMz3}P09{|1t= b4.}~!(}" RR,,'F= 2[\WG06r#$E40TZ UVQ%g &`RmQ?[\h=T'()*+{ ,-./,0M%1w= of!23(45PVx 'F0R,@5,0U/67q knoH >kupqr+Hk9:]^_= sVit= uvUwxo(yM b4,050'F09t+;?@A-.38> * ) + !"#!! $" !%# $" &$ !"#$%&'()*+,-./0 !" # ##$%&'()*+,-./012 '()A 'V*+k,-./9[6 ./8 34526 7,849&:;3<=6 >? ]4|fGHlm5n&f0EvcX1 84@ABCDE F4GHIJK 4LMN JN4@H2[>3&+,E jk45c4 &OPQRS'()*6 TUVWOXYZ Y56)*wW`UVIxzW6 78K 4 [5\]^_&`a2bc6 defghi 9K p:K ;<'[F4565w&H=c F4jk205c&l`mDno6 pqr )6 >?@4AX1BCyz@! stuAB&.v30wxyz{|fj k}~! !8901:;<=>?@ !j"# DE'+4@OPMNJ^K 4@rFK 5 !"#$%&'( !j"#f$%) )XG]&j`H88FIEH8(^I *+,6 -&'())*6 *'+,-i. J6 -`5b2K3LMLN6 [4@PO /06 1233\g=4j`5)673v f'UPK 2Q2UK RSPLL-m5b 8j`5I9:3;!<=6 > ?@A K >B TU3jkIJVW!<=6 X4dYZ[ CA +D\EFGHI36q $% &&JKL (J/\PU[]2(JK j"(JK ^P M_NOPQR&\EFS-GHI+, (J3<_(J )`sa6 [bVFscd TUIP'V6 NW4LNXYZ6 [\X ]4|a(Jef&IJ32K6 '[4@ ]4\EFGHI5w&*'3J^_` POH,VFsPUP&jkIJ67E 6 8jkabE cde6fe'()*8gh qghiGjk&#jk/06 '[ ' # # *$ ij6 klm\n\oK \pqrcdst lmnopqr2MNL(R4Lpqr fue3ve]wWxyzWE > {|}~ 2st]6 F4st/0PO&jk9u! !"#\g/u$wA %"016 kF4& 'H5s(^)|*+&%"ij6 J^" #\g&$w)*,+6 \X8&'5r& "-123"#$%&')*456 7/089 -\3/u$w&J^E 5b@-`n.& IJvwo#]5!wo,+&$ /031/26348`r56-)*7 %!FxyczIJvwo1{6 |}2~ 86 IP`&569:;<`K `=>&? j`'J5`[=!&IJvwo,+6 " @ABCD6 uE8]4`F@bKG9: /jt#IJv#$./8j`'J5`6 PH&<\YZ! %"/j'MIJvfVq5[j )*+,+-./0123456 `'J5`&'(k(!jkJ)5)w 7!j"#(JKzWKIx5)'J6*' o& "*kW+ ,( -o_=!kW!.+j` 15cK 10KK 15wL6 MNOPgQR 'J5`6 /01a/!6 '.5).1' S6 HkTUVgQK WXEK YZEK [> J&5bo_KOPMN23E ,' -&#k \f]6 e8k-^5w_`aK `bcd W!45IJ/!3J^676 89IJv e[K fgfghiL/j&kW!<=6 cd:g6 -^.1FaE ," -;rkW!t |f]4GHlm5n3jk[>o_& # >"<=A >?@'AB6 t#IJv&* pqrstu.1vw6 '[]4xyzF +K ]C3k4D9EMa&|F! Ww{&1v3|v6 |fxy&}~zW TUJ)E4G@kwo]&kW6 H o_3!|&[>"#E ' # ( '$6 >|%%& Ig0TEK vJKLK =M(NK f!O& !" ! " # !" ! " ! " ! " " # $ % & ' # "( ) ( ) !"#$%&'()*+,-./012345 >$%56Pt@'I{7 &'()56PRX* 67 89:;<=()*>?-.'@A/0BA +/,-./056P1{7 231{456gW 56CDE(FGHI7 JK:; 77 89C]T #$Z^7 :ijk;rHI UVWXT YZ[\T ]^_Z7 `(aQJbcd ! " ! " t xy!"'aQ7 k-56P?zM r@A ef'gh/ijklmnopqWXC56 r( =t BC'xy!"D7 mzME56P'J{W st 7 uvwxyT mzJ{T |}a~Jb!F! XT t@xyC89!"/ r@A=t 9F(7 G0H "`#$%&'/>(7 )*!5+,-.pq( !"D*?]^7 I56P`f'Jb>YuJ )*-.'/07 1c2345T 67HI'"G {7 9Y r;<=t -.W$RXAJC56P`a 89/ bycdef7 #$KxyZc[\7 @uk05 9: r;<=t xy7 >fJbHI?@7 >f 6P_Z'J9&'/ 56WX'!"ABCCDEFGH7 >f56P 89:1;<=>/UVLMYt xyZc[\]^7 ;O12_56P`a qrs&7 ukPNVpWCX`,Y`#Z[$ bycdef/ %7 \@u r;<=t -.W$RXC rJb>Yt x !"#$%&'()*+ /k0gO56P ' yZc[\]^'$%P'/ chi;j r;<=t -.W$RX7 kl?-.CAM-.7 m<=KnC<.o3 xRGaE`RG']]7 45CLNJbcde '(d7 #$56P'noCpqrs&7 #$J fWX'RGST7 I!FRG]]'>Yb^E {pqt@*i[\7 NO56P]*t@T :i Wc']]C_ZHI7 u rHI ! " ! " t `#:i IJTuv>wx7aQJb>YCyz{|: ^&7 d!FSe]]',?f7 iLgHI%< i/i r;<=t -.W$RX|}}7 ~!%"# .'*hi:;j!F<.k' rlmnt @A/ !"# $% & $#'()) *+,./ 0. 1 2 $341 $5. % 6.7. 8 $%!*9:01 ; $&" <$% 2 " 31 " 6)= > 1 "& () *+,-./ * o+,* .0 1 023 ) 40 567893 * 0 .3 0 1# "" :;&(0 * < * .= p (?> 1 % .; 1>,0+755-.* 1 ?@) A ? 678+,* .)B +@+C D 1+0 .? A ) /+755* ? ? 0 0) .4? ,09? ) ? 0+7-.3 * /3 7.E0 .0 4? ,0F) ? * 7.) /93 * 0 .3 0) .4 >0 3 ,.7/ 7=6G ..7E) ? * 7.+7.8 0 A 0 .3 07.H -/ 6;7) .4* 1 1 -0 4)473 -50 .? I.) 50 / 6 IJK* .* 7.17.L0 0 K0 .* .=? ,0M0 8 7A 578? ,09N> 961 ? 0 5) .423 3 0 / 0 A ) ? * .=? ,0L0 E0 / 7K50 .?78)F) ? * 7.) /G ..7E) ? * 7.961 ? 0 5$>,0473 -50 .?,) 140 8 * .0 4? ,07O< 0 3 ? * E0 1 IKA * 7A * ? * 0 1 ) .4? ) 1 P178? ,09N>1 61 ? 0 5A 0 8 7A 5I) .4KA 7K71 0 4? ,0* 5K/ 0 50 .? ) ? * 7.78)K* / 7?KA 7< 0 3 ?8 7A5) < 7AMNL7-? 3 750 Q 7A * 0 .? 0 49N> 0 E) / -) ? * 7.$G .7A 40 A? 78 -/ 8 * / /? ,01 ? A ) ? 0 =* 3=7) / 1) .4? ) 1 P178G ..7E) ? * 7.! "! " I? ,0+,* .0 1 023 ) 40 567893 * 0 .3 0 1B +29C,) 1KA 7Q K71 0 4)A 0 8 7A 578* ? 19N>0 E) / -) ? * 7.? 740 E0 / 7K)5) < 7AMNL7-? 3 750Q 7A * 0 .? 0 40 E) / -) ? * 7.1 61 ? 0 5$>,* 1) A ? * 3 / 00 / ) O7A ) ? 0 1? ,0 * 5K7A ? ) .3 078A 0 8 7A 5* .=? ,09N>0 E) / -) ? * 7.? 7R) A 4)S) < 7AMNLJ-? 3 750 Q 7A * 0 .? 0 41 61 ? 0 5) .4? ,0KA 78 7-.4* 5K/ * 3 ) ? * 7.178 S) < 7AMNLJ-? 3 750 I) .4* .? A 74-3 0 1? ,0+29* .1 ? * ? -? 0 Q O) 1 0 4S) < 7AMNLJ-? 3 750Q 7A * 0 .? 0 40 E) / -) ? * 7.1 61 ? 0 5$>,* 1KA 7) 3 ? * E0 0 8 8 7A ?78+29* .A 0 8 7A 5* .=* ? 19N>1 61 ? 0 5,) 140 57.1 ? A ) ? 0 4* ? 1/ 0 ) 4* .=A 7/ 0) 1? ,0F) ? * 7.) />0 ) 5* .9N>L0 E0 / 7K50 .? $ @" =5$% 6>+,* .0 1 023 ) 40 567893 * 0 .3 0 1 75) < 7AMNL7-? 3 750 79N>0 E) / -) ? * 7. * + ) !"#!! $" !%# $" &$